Lost Diner Exterior_Untapped Cities_New York_Will Ellis
The “Lost Diner” at 357 West Street

New York City isn’t known for its roadside attractions or its motor inns, but along the West Side Highway, you can still find shades of the open road.  What could be more emblematic of the highway state of mind than the diner, whose very contours suggest forward motion, gleaming like hubcaps across the American landscape?  Abandoned between auto repair shops and a gentlemen’s club, the lost diner at 357 West Street fully commits to the mystery and isolation only hinted at in Edward Hopper’s Nighthawks, (which happens to be based on a nearby diner in Greenwich Village.)  Untapped Cities previously covered the history of the diner, but today we can’t resist taking a peek inside… 

Lost Diner_Untapped Cities_New York_Will Ellis
Inside an abandoned diner on the West Side Highway.

The restaurant closed in 2006 after 50 years of operation, having gone through a steady succession of owners and names, including the Terminal Diner, the Lunchbox Diner, Rib, and perhaps most fittingly, the Lost Diner.  Constructed by the New Jersey-based Kullman Diner Car Company, the structure is typical of the Art-Deco diner cars manufactured in the ’40s and ’50s, which have since become an iconic fixture of cities across America.

Diner Bathroom_Untapped Cities_New York_Will Ellis
“Employees must wash hands”

Most of Manhattan’s once numerous diners have been demolished or moved in recent years; you can still visit Soho’s famous Moondance Diner—in Wyoming.  Unfortunately, the Lost Diner’s chances for relocation are fading fast.  Since the last time we visited the 357 West Street, vandals have knocked out the windows and laid waste to the interior.

Broken Mirrors_Untapped Cities_New York_Will Ellis
Valuable scrap metal has been lifted from the walls.

In the dining room, shattered glass joins a host of reflective surfaces, causing the room to glimmer with points of light in the evening.  Sunlight bounced from a passing windshield momentarily dazzles an aluminum ceiling. In the absence of clinking silverware, the rush of the highway fills the space.

Diner Entrance_Untapped Cities_New York_Will Ellis
Gaping windows and remnants of a recent squat at the lost diner’s entrance.

Old mattresses, fresh garbage, and a homemade toilet point to a recent, if not ongoing habitation.  Stacks of rotting food cartons fill an overturned refrigerator, covered with the husks of long-dead pests.  In the former kitchen, a dry erase board lists celery seed, walnut oil, and Windex for a shopping trip that was doomed to be this diner’s last…

Freezer_Untapped Cities_New York_Will Ellis
An empty pantry in the back of the lost diner.

For more photos and the history behind New York City’s abandoned places, check out Will’s website, abandonednyc.com, and follow him on Facebook for updates and new locations.

2 thoughts on “Inside The West Side Highway’s Lost Diner

  1. Thanks for the info, Phil. It seems like the Nighthawks location is a heavily debated subject! Do you remember the name of the book?

  2. Great article! Just one thing though is that the Hopper “Nighthawks” has been pretty thoroughly researched and is believed to have either been a fictional creation of Hopper’s or a culmination of several different NY spots. There’s a great book about Nighthawks which explores the theories. Amazing how much one painting can still stir the imagination. It is an utter shame that diners have fallen by the wayside in New York. It is as lost an icon of NY street life as if we were to lose numbered streets. The Empire, the City Diner, etc etc etc… Wake up, NY. Your great and storied past need not end up like the pictures in this article.

Comments are closed.