2. Little Pie Company

Nestled into a small brick wall in Hell’s Kitchen, Little Pie Company can be spotted by a simple green awning and a mouth-watering window display of desserts. The bakery has been established since 1985 and offers pies of three different sizes: 5 inch, 8 inch, and 10 inch. They refrain from using anything artificial or chemical in their desserts and, instead, boast a commitment to pure, fresh ingredients. The store is open every day of the week, however, in case you can’t make it in, they also ship to any location in the US (though beware of the overnight shipping fee)!