5. Pizza Suprema

Pizza Suprema-8th Avenue-Penn Station-Madison Square Garden-New York Pizza Project-NYC

Most people have no idea that there is good food near Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. Not just good food, but maybe the best slice in all of New York. The Riggio family has been in the location even before the current Madison Square Garden was built. They make three different sauces, depending on what slice you get, and have a world famous upside down slice, rivaled only by Prince Street Pizza.

Located at: 413 8th Ave, New York, NY