4. Faicco’s

faiccos butcher shop

Located almost directly across the street from Ottomanelli & Sons, Faicco’s contributes to the old-school vibe of Bleecker Street with Italian specialties and the fact that they have been in business since 1900 doesn’t hurt either. Although they are known for sausage and pork, products range from sandwiches to cold cuts as well. For those that aren’t in the mood for something as heavy, a fan favorite is the homemade arancini. Faicco’s is open Tuesday through Sunday.