5. L. Simchick & Co.
Located at 988 1st Avenue, L. Simchick & Co. brings a quality prime meat and poultry selection to Midtown Manhattan with beef, veal, lamb and poultry products available for purchase for orders large or small. Although one of the youngest on this list, L. Simchick & Co. has been in business since 1992. L. Simchick & Co. puts a special emphasis on locally sourced products, custom orders and organic ingredients when available. This butcher shop is open Monday through Saturday.