10. Foster Sundry

It’s last on our list, but certainly not least. Almost everything in this Bushwick eatery, located on 215 Knickerbocker Avenue at Troutman Street, is made in-house, from the sauerkraut to the special sauce. Come for the smoky and savory sandwiches, but don’t leave without trying a honey biscuit. It’s the sweet and sticky treat you need to compliment the vinegary, tart main course.

Foster Sundry also allows online orders of its famous meats and other grocery items. Although the option is only offered in New York City so far, you can hop on the sign-up list to be notified when the service goes nationwide.

Next, check out the History of the NYC Bagel and read about 12 Foods That Were Invented in NYC. Also read about the World’s Largest Lox Bagel.