The Bronx’s famous Arthur Avenue continues to be a center of Italian-American New York. With its numerous restaurants, bakeries, and rich history, this small street near Fordham University continues to dazzle tourists and New Yorkers, alike and is sometimes referred to as the “Real Little Italy.” However, what even many New Yorkers may not know is that the famous street has a fascinating history that dates back more than 200 years. Here are ten of Arthur Avenue’s biggest secrets:
On May 4th, you can enjoy a taste of the Bronx’s Little Italy on an Untapped New York Insiders tour and tasting at the Arthur Avenue Retail Market! On this experience led by professional tour guide Dario Chiazzolino, guests will get to indulge in delicious samples from vendors including DUA Gourmet Market, Bronx Beer Hall, and La Rossa Pizza, as well as watch demonstrations at La Casa Grande Cigars and Mike’s Deli! This event is free for Untapped New York Insiders. Not an Insider yet? Become a member today for member-exclusive in-person and virtual experiences all year long!
Arthur Ave Market Tour & Tasting
1. The Surrounding Neighborhood Was a Tobacco Plant
Arthur Avenue’s long history begins in 1760, when French Huguenot Pierre Lorillard moved to New York from France and began his famous tobacco company, P. Lorillard & Co., which still exists today under the Loews Corporation. In 1778, at the time of the Revolutionary War, Lorillard was killed, leaving the company to his widow and five sons. Following his death, the family moved North to a large section of land along the Bronx River, and opened a new tobacco producing plant. The largest building of the plant, known today as the Lorillard Snuff Mill, is still standing within the walls of the New York Botanical Garden, near where the grand Lorillard mansion once stood.
For nearly one hundred years, the family owned and operated the tobacco company in the present-day Belmont neighborhood. In 1870, Catherine Lorillard-Wolfe inherited her great grandfather’s vast estate of tobacco manufacturing businesses and—at the time—became the richest woman in America. Upon her acquisition of the estate, she auctioned it off in two sections: the land of the Belmont neighborhood, which was divided by streets and neighborhoods, and the Lorillard Mansion, which became the modern-day St. Barnabas Hospital and Medical Center.
2. The Street is Named After President Arthur
At the time of the estate’s sale, Catherine Lorillard-Wolfe was a great admirer of President Chester A. Arthur. Prior to her death, Lorillard-Wolfe showed her admiration for the 21st president by naming the main street of the new Belmont neighborhood after him.
Similarly, many of Arthur Avenue’s neighboring streets were named after influential figures of the mid-nineteenth century: Hughes Avenue was named after the founder of Fordham University and the first Archbishop of New York, John Hughes; Hoffman Street was named after John Thomas Hoffman, the 23rd governor of New York and previous Mayor of New York; and Bathgate Avenue was named after Scottish immigrant Andrew Bathgate, who managed the estate of one of the Bronx’s original founders.
3. Arthur Avenue Began as a Push Cart Market
In the 1930s and 40s, Arthur Avenue became a center for Bronx life and commerce. The famous shops and restaurants which line today’s Arthur Avenue used to be traveling push carts owned by Irish and Italian immigrants, who often sold fresh produce and goods. During this time, the Italian population of Arthur Avenue was exponentially increasing as the Bronx’s cultural identity began to take root. Many predominate ad campaigns referred to the Belmont area as “an Italian colony in America,” with Arthur Avenue at the center.
Although Arthur Avenue’s push cart market may be a Bronx-favorite, New York is home to many other famous push cart locations. On Essex Street, the push cart business was alive and well inside Essex Street Market, which recently moved across the street to the New Essex Market. In both Manhattan and the Bronx, these reinvented spaces offered new takes on their historic push cart roots.
4. Arthur Avenue Retail Market was the First Enclosed Market in the Bronx
To cater to the needs of hundreds of thousands of shoppers on Arthur Avenue and the cart owners, the Arthur Avenue Retail Market was opened by Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia at 2344 Arthur Avenue in 1940. The market offered stalls to push cart owners for a small fee and allowed for a better shopping experience for customers. Later, the market was converted into the Italian-product marketplace that it is today.
Today the market hosts a variety of diverse specialty vendors such as the Bronx Beer Hall, Felix’s Custom T-Shirts and Alterations, O’CCAFFE, and Funici A’Pizza, O’CCAFFE, Enzo’s of Arthur Avenue on the Go, La Casa Grande Cigars, and Peter’s Meat Market. On our upcoming Untapped New York Insiders tour to the market, we’ll stop by the women-owned DUA Market which sells Balkan and Italian products. We’ll also see a mozzarella-making demonstration at Mike’s Deli where we’ll sample their renowned Eggplant Parmigiana that was seen on the Food Network, when Dave Greco, the second-generation owner of Mike’s Deli, defended his family’s recipe on “Throwdown with Bobby Flay.” Find out what else you’ll get to enjoy at the link below!
Arthur Ave Market Tour & Tasting
Similarly, many other enclosed markets can be found around New York. Chelsea Market, for example, is another enclosed market that features vendors from around the city – albeit more upscale. Both the Arthur Avenue Retail Market and Chelsea Market occupy important roles in New York history—all while serving delicious food.
5. Musical Group Dion and the Belmonts Originated on Arthur Avenue
The 1950s boyband Dion and the Belmonts originated on Arthur Avenue but was named after Belmont Avenue, a close distance from Arthur Avenue. The group gained fame for becoming the first Italian-American group to become popular performing “doo-wop” style music. Their first single in 1958, “I Wonder Why,” skyrocketed the group to stardom, followed by other hits such as “A Teenager in Love” and “Where or When.”
Dion DiMucci, the group’s lead singer, later left the band and pursued a successful solo career which spanned several decades. His songs “Runaround Sue” and “The Wanderer” helped establish DiMucci’s stardom by earning him an impressive 39 Top 40 hits. Later in 1989, DiMucci was inducted in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
6. The Oscar-Winning Film Marty was Shot on There
The 1955, 4-time Academy Award-winning film Marty was based and shot on Arthur Avenue. The film’s main character, Marty Piletti, worked on Arthur Avenue at a meat market—which he considers buying in the movie. In 1994, Marty was selected for preservation in the National Film Registry and also in the Library of Congress.
Similarly, Arthur Avenue also inspired the movie A Bronx Tale, which starred Robert De Niro, Chazz Palminteri, and Lillo Brancato Jr. Despite being met with moderate commercial success, the film was beloved by critics and remains a Bronx favorite, today. Just one block from Arthur Avenue, you can spot a mural on the side of a Bronx car wash that advertises the movie’s backdrop as right around the corner on Arthur Avenue.
7. Mario’s Restaurant Made a Soprano’s Cameo
In 2003, the Arthur Avenue restaurant, Mario’s Restaurant, became the setting of what TV Guide rated as the best TV show of all time, The Sopranos. This 21-time Emmy Award winning show revolves around the life of Tony Soprano, a mobster whose often caught between his love for his family and the dark nature of his work. The appearance of Mario’s Restaurant in season five of the hit show was widely beloved by Bronxites and showcased the delicious Italian cuisine at Mario’s Restaurant.
Mario’s Restaurant is celebrating its 100th anniversary this year and remains family owned by Joseph Migliucci, the fourth generation of his family to run the restaurant. From a six-table pizza shop to the bustling restaurant today that can serve 400 people each day, Mario’s is a Bronx institution.
8. Arthur Avenue Once Had a Reality Show
In the age of the Kardashians and the Real Housewives, reality television has become a favorite of American television viewers. This fascination with reality television made its way to Arthur Avenue in 2012 with the premiere of Mama’s Boys of the Bronx, a television show which aired on TLC for only one season. The series revolves around the lives of five Bronx men who still live at home with their mothers, despite their mature antics.
The show only lasted for a single season before it was cancelled. Popular reaction and reviews of the show were mixed. More than the characters within the show, the recognition of the Bronx’s Little Italy boosted Arthur Avenue’s visibility to a wider audience.
9. A Lady Gaga Music Video Was Filmed on Arthur Avenue
The world-renowned pop icon Lady Gaga channeled her Italian-American heritage by shooting the music video for her song, “Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)” on Arthur Avenue. This gold-certified hit was met with mixed reviews from critics but was loved by her fans. Much of the music video includes imagery of feminine Italian-American strength by contrasting Lady Gaga fulfilling traditionally feminine and masculine stereotypes.
In the same ways that Lady Gaga was inspired by the unique culture of Arthur Avenue, many artists draw inspiration from New York neighborhoods. Check out 12 Places in NYC that Inspired Great Music a few iconic neighborhoods and places which inspired iconic music.
10. Arthur Avenue Was Named One of “America’s Greatest Streets”
Since its origin as a push-cart marketplace, Arthur Avenue has been an Italian-American cultural epicenter and place of refuge for immigrants from around the world. In 2016, the American Planning Association named Arthur Avenue one of the “Great Streets of America” for its significant contribution to Italian-American cultural identity and art, alongside the avenue’s plethora of delicious restaurants.
Whether tourists come to visit the Ferragosto Festival or Bronxites grabbing a bite to eat at one of the many restaurants which Arthur Ave has to offer, the significance of Arthur Avenue to the Bronx Community—and the Greater City of New York—is important to the city’s history as a haven for immigrants. For more information, visit the avenue’s website.
This article was written by Mason Rowlee
Next make sure to check out 10 Abandoned Places to Discover in the Bronx, NYC and The Top 6 Oldest Buildings in The Bronx, NYC