10. Defonte’s Sandwich Shop (1922)

Defonte’s Sandwich Shop is located at 379 Columbia Street in Red Hook, Brooklyn, founded in 1922 by Nick Defonte, an Italian immigrant from Bari, Italy who came through Ellis Island. Defonte bought the store for $100 from a mysterious man named Brooklyn who needed to urgently leave town, and the almost 100 year-old-institution has been making enormous subway sandwiches ever since. Defonte’s has been continuously family run since then as well, with a more recent outpost opened on Staten Island. The owners aim to keep that old-school feeling, telling CBS News earlier this year, “You walk in here, and it’s like you’re transported back in the day. There’s people yelling left and right. There’s sandwiches being thrown.”

Next, check out the 13 oldest restaurants in NYC.

View all on one page

2 Responses
  1. Apparently you left out, if you want to talk first and old;
    1762 Fraunces Tavern
    1794 Bridge Cafe
    1817 The Ear Inn
    1837 Delmonico
    1864 Pete’s Tavern
    1868 Homestead Steakhouse
    1880 White Horse Tavern
    1884 PJ’s Clarke’s
    1885 Keen’s Steakhouse
    Oh wait, I see you did do a diff post with these

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *