10. The restaurant has its own grittier history as well
But it wasn’t all just fun and books. There were definitely some grittier stories from Chumley’s history. Newsweek reported that a chess match went astray in the bar in 1960 when a writer was killed by a sailor with a beer bottle. In 1964, a sculptor was mugged and then shot when leaving the bar. And in 1974, a heroin addict who had just committed a murder was found hiding in the Chumley’s boiler room. AND, last but not least, Leland Chumley’s wife’s ghost supposedly still haunts the place…
You can easily step back in time at Chumley’s, by booking a reservation online from their website. It’s great for a meal or just a drink at the bar. And sign up for advance notice of our new speakeasy tour!
Next, check out 10 of the Oldest Surviving Bars in Manhattan.