4. 129 Spring Street (COS Clothing Store)
In the basement of the store is the 200+-year old “haunted” well involved in the Levi Weeks murder case (where Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr served as defense counsels for Weeks). The woman Weeks was accused of murdering was found in this well, and there have been reports of strange happenings around the well over the years.
The sepcific location is not in the musical, but the subsequent murder trial of Levi Weeks, who is defended by Hamilton and Burr, is mentioned in “Non Stop.” In the lower level of the store, the well is still there and can be seen by visitors, incongruously surrounded by clothing displays.