St. John the Divine
Photo Courtesy of St. John the Divine

The Cathedral of Saint John the Divine on Amsterdam Avenue is not only one of the oldest buildings in Morningside Heights but also one of the most fascinating. The historic cathedral has many secrets, from a gold triptych by Keith Haring to a very unusual sculpture featuring the Archangel Michael, the decapitated head of Satan, and nine giraffes. Here are ten secrets of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine!

Vertical Tour of St. John the Divine

St. John the Divine

You can join us to uncover more on an Untapped New York Insiders Vertical tour of St. John the Divine on September 2nd or 6th! This exclusive tour will feature a stop at the Guastavino staircase, a feature you won’t see on any other tour of the cathedral. Tickets are $20 for Untapped New York Insiders. Not an Insider yet? Become a member today and get your first month free with code JOINUS.

1. The Keith Haring Triptych 

Keith Haring Triptych at St. John the Divine

“The Life of Christ” was Keith Haring’s last work before his death. He passed away just weeks after this work was complete. There are nine versions of this triptych, cast in bronze and covered in white gold, one of which is located at St. John the Divine. Another version can be seen in Paris at Saint Eustache, which we covered in our NYC vs Paris series, and another is located in Grace Cathedral in San Francisco. The three panels represent the life of Jesus Christ, his resurrection, and a fallen angel.

2. The Cathedral was never finished

Ceiling of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine

A Guide to the Cathedral from 1921 posited that it might take 700 years for the Cathedral to be completed since it was built by employing true Gothic building methods. However, as of now, it appears that the Cathedral will never be completed. A “temporary” ceiling consisting of tiles is still in place a century after it was supposed to be demolished so that the Cathedral’s spire could rise.

Additionally, the crossing was never completed, resulting in an extremely truncated cruciform layout. For photos of what the Cathedral was supposed to look like upon completion check out our previous coverage in The NYC that Never Was: The Half-Finished St. John the Divine.

3. Abraham Lincoln, Albert Einstein, and More Are Honored in Stone

  • Abraham Lincoln Statue in St. John the Divine
  • Statue in St. John the Divine
  • Statue in St. John the Divine
  • George Washington Statue in St. John the Divine
  • Statue in St. John the Divine

In 1922, at a cost of $16,000, the Cathedral installed a stone parapet. The parapet contained “one sculpture for each of the Christian centuries, each figure being that of the personage who in that 100 years did the most, in the opinion of the Cathedral authorities, for the uplift of the world.” The twentieth-century niche was left empty with instructions that it was to remain empty for seventy-eight years in order to determine who would be worthy of filling the void for the century. According to the New York Times, the front runners in 1922 were Theodore Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, Lloyd George, and Charles Evans Hughes. The niche was eventually filled with a statue of Martin Luther King Jr., Susan B. Anthony, Einstein, and Gandhi carved by Chris Pellettieri.

4. Resting Place of Madeleine L’Engle

Madeleine L'Engle resting place

Madeleine L’Engle is most famously known for writing the Newberry prize winning young adult novel, A Wrinkle in Time. However, in addition to being an author, L’Engle was a devout Episcopalian. She served as a volunteer librarian and writer in residence at the Cathedral of Saint John the Divine. When she passed away in 2007, she was inurned in the Cathedral.

5. Largest Rose Window in the United States

Cathedral of Saint John the Divine Rose Window Stained Glass Window

St.John the Divine claims to be the largest cathedral in the world, defined as a church that is also the seat of a bishop. (St. Peter’s, for example, is not a cathedral). Measured by length or internal volume, it is one of the five largest church buildings in the world. Additionally, it possesses the largest rose window in the United States. The window, which is the fifth largest in the world, was constructed out of 10,000 pieces of stained glass.

6. A Television Hidden in Stained Glass

Cathedral of Saint John the Divine Upper West Side Stained Glass Windows

In addition to having numerous stained glass windows that depict Biblical and post-Biblical religious scenes, Saint John the Divine has a plethora of modern imagery hidden throughout their stained glass windows. The Nave features fourteen themed bays, which honor professions and human endeavors. The Cathedral claims that any profession can fit into one of these themes, which include Communications, Medicine, Law, and Sports. The themed bays juxtapose traditional religious imagery with modern and secular images, including a 1925 prototype television, a train, Betsy Ross, Robert E. Lee, and even the sinking of the Titanic.

7. Gifts from All Over the World

Siamese cabinet gift of king Cathedral of saint john the divine upper west side

As evidenced above through the topics depicted in its stained glass windows, Saint John the Divine has embraced the multi-national demographics that make up its congregation. According to the Cathedral,  it was chartered as “a house of prayer for all people.”The Chapels of the Tongues, located behind the High Altar, are dedicated to, and have design elements referencing, seven immigrant groups that settled in the United States in the early twentieth century. Additionally, the Cathedral possesses two Japanese cloisonné vases donated by the Japanese ambassador in 1926 on behalf of Japan, and a pair of teak Siamese Book Cabinets that were a gift of the King of Siam, in 1930.

8. The Oldest Building in Morningside Heights

St. John the Divine orphanage

Just south of the Cathedral is a Greek Revival building that predates Saint John the Divine’s tenure on the Upper West Side. It was constructed in 1843 as the Leake and Watts Orphan Asylum and was designed by Ithiel Towne, who also designed Federal Hall. In 1891, the Asylum moved to Westchester, and Saint John the Divine intended to demolish the building in order to build the Cathedral’s crossing. For a number of years, the church let the building deteriorate with the hopes that it would just fall down. Ultimately, the building was restored and now houses a state-of-the-art Tapestry and Textile Conservation Laboratory as well as other Cathedral functions.

9. Decapitated Head of Satan, Peacocks, and More

Peace Fountain-Cathedral St John the Divine-Decapitated Satan-Giraffes-DNA-NYC

Just south of the Cathedral, lies its 11.3 acre close or campus. Visitors can stroll through a biblical garden, where the different plants are all species mentioned in the Bible One of the close highlights is the Peace Fountain, designed in 1985 by Greg Wyatt. The fountain was created to mark the 200th anniversary of the Diocese of New York. It depicts the Archangel Michael embracing one of the nine giraffes after his defeat of Satan. There is also a lion lying down with a lamb. The fountain’s spiraling base represents a double helix of DNA. The close is where the Cathedral’s trio of peacocks used to roam, but they retired in January 2023.

Additionally, the Children’s Sculpture Garden, a series of small bronze animal sculptures created by local K-12 students surrounds the fountain. For more information on the Peace Fountain check out our previous article Daily What?! The Peace Fountain at Saint John the Divine features the Decapitated Head of Satan and 9 Giraffes!

10. Vertical Tours

  • A tour group on the roof
  • Staircase

St. John the Divine is one of the few places left in New York City that allows visitors to access its roof and a unique vista of the City. In addition to offering some insight into the Cathedral’s history and iconography, the tour allows visitors to come face to face with the stained glass windows and to get a spectacular view that on a clear day can included the spire of One World Trade Center.

Vertical Tour of St. John the Divine

St. John the Divine

You can join Untapped New York Insiders for an exclusive members-only vertical tour that includes an extra, special stop that isn’t usually on the tour route!

Next, check out the Secrets of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Top 10 Secrets of Grand Central Terminal, and Secrets of the New York Public Library