The recent debate over what should become of the current Penn Station and Madison Square Garden might make it difficult for some to imagine the “World’s Most Famous Arena” existing somewhere else, but the venue has a history of moving around. In fact, the current arena is actually the fourth Madison Square Garden to exist.

The first arena to bear the name was located right by Madison Square Park and became a reality with the help of P.T. Barnum who first made it his “Great Roman Hippodrome.” After being leased and passed along a few more times, the arena finally became Madison Square Garden in 1879 under William Kissam Vanderbilt but the building (which had no roof) was eventually demolished in 1889.

Barnum's Hippodrome New-York-Untapped-Cities
P.T. Barnum’s “Great Roman Hippodrome”

The next incarnation was designed by architect Stanford White in Moorish style and opened in 1890, becoming the second tallest building in the city. White, who had an apartment in the building, was later murdered during a show in 1906 for his affair with actress Evelyn Nesbit by her husband Henry Kendall Thaw in an event that would be sensationalized by the press. Despite its grand structure and cost, the Garden was once again demolished in 1925.

Madison Square Garden I Exterior New-York-Untapped-CitiesMadison Square Garden I

The third Madison Square Garden took the arena away from Madison Square Park and opened in 1925 as a simpler looking structure, designed by Thomas W. Lamb. The venue, located at 8th Avenue between 49th and 50th Streets, had problems from the start, as many seats had obstructed views. It was again closed in 1968, making way for the fourth (and so far, final) Madison Square Garden, designed by Charles Luckman. The construction was arguably the most controversial as the arena replaced the original Penn Station, which had been designed by McKim, Mead & White, in 1968. The two sites have been linked since as debates regarding them continue.

The Garden as we know it has come along way. See how it once looked in these photos of its first three incarnations.

Madison_Square_Garden_1890 New-York-Untapped-CitiesMadison Square Garden II

Madison Square Garden (poster) (1900) New-York-Untapped-CitiesMadison Square Garden II Poster

W. J. Bryan demonstration at Madison Square Garden, New York (1906) New-York-Untapped-CitiesDemonstration in honor of W. J. Bryan, at Madison Square Garden (1906)

Madison_Square_Garden_1907 New-York-Untapped-CitiesMadison Square Garden, 1907

1925 Madison Square Garden program New-York-Untapped-CitiesMadison Square Garden III Poster

Madison Square Garden III New-York-Untapped-CitiesMadison Square Garden III. Image Credit: The Madison Square Garden Company

Photos from the New York Public Library and Wikimedia Commons.

See more from our Vintage Photography column and get in touch with the author.

 Madison Square Garden, madison square park, P.T. Barnum, penn station, vintage photos

2 Responses
  1. Thanks for this posting. MSG II is my favorite building in NYC and so sad it is lost. Really am interested in learning about what became of the material when the building was razed. Anything salvaged/reused anywhere?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *