8. Jayne Tavern

Setauket Jayne Tavern-Massacre-Culper Spy Ring-AMC TURN-Film Locations-Abraham Woodhull Grave-Revolutionary War-Long Island
During the war, Jayne Tavern, also on Main Street but closer to the Village Green than Roe Tavern, was the site of a bloody massacre. The British came looking for deserters and opened fire, leaving four Americans dead. According to the Three Village Historical Society, bullet holes are still visible in the house, which is now private.